Doctrines compared

Who believes what

Faded = divided.

The Trinity

Nearly all churches confess one God in three co-equal, co-eternal Persons. Arians (4th c.) denied the Son’s full divinity; modern Jehovah’s Witnesses hold a similar view, Latter-day Saints teach three separate beings, and Oneness Pentecostals see one Person in three manifestations.

Matthew 28:19John 1:1–142 Corinthians 13:14

Nicaea (325) declared the Son “of one substance” (homoousios) with the Father; Constantinople (381) affirmed the Spirit’s divinity.

Who is God?

Scripture & Authority

Catholics and Orthodox receive Scripture within Holy Tradition, guarded by bishops. The Reformers taught sola Scriptura: Scripture as the only infallible rule, with creeds and confessions subordinate. Anglicans and Methodists speak of Scripture as primary but read with tradition and reason. Some groups add modern prophets or new scripture; Quakers stress the Inner Light.

2 Timothy 3:16–172 Thessalonians 2:151 Timothy 3:15

Luther at Worms (1521): “Unless I am convinced by Scripture and plain reason… I cannot and will not recant.”

What has the final word on doctrine?

The Papacy

Catholics hold that Christ made Peter head of the apostles and that the Bishop of Rome inherits that office with full, supreme and universal jurisdiction, and can speak infallibly ex cathedra. Orthodox grant Rome a historic “primacy of honour” among equals; Protestants reject the papal claim altogether.

Matthew 16:18–19Luke 22:32John 21:15–17

The mutual excommunications of 1054 crystallised the East–West split; Vatican I (1870) defined papal infallibility.

Does the Pope hold supreme authority over the whole Church?

Ecumenical Councils

Councils of bishops settled the great disputes about Christ and the Trinity. The number a church accepts is one of the clearest dividing lines: 2 (Church of the East), 3 (Oriental Orthodox), 7 (Eastern Orthodox), 21 (Catholic). Classical Protestants accept the early councils insofar as they agree with Scripture.

Acts 15:1–29

Chalcedon (451) defined Christ as one Person “in two natures” — the definition that divided Chalcedonian and Oriental churches.

Which church councils carry binding authority?

The Eucharist

Catholics teach transubstantiation: the substance of bread and wine becomes Christ’s body and blood. Orthodox affirm a real change but decline to define how. Lutherans confess Christ’s body “in, with and under” the elements. Calvin taught a real but spiritual presence; Zwingli and most Baptists see a memorial. Quakers practise no outward rite.

John 6:51–58Matthew 26:26–281 Corinthians 10:16; 11:23–29

The Marburg Colloquy (1529) — Luther and Zwingli agreed on 14 of 15 articles, but not on the Supper.

What happens in Communion?

  • Transubstantiation
  • Real change (mystery)
  • Sacramental union
  • Spiritual presence
  • Memorial
  • Inward only

Baptism

Most historic churches baptise infants and teach that baptism brings new birth (baptismal regeneration). Reformed churches baptise infants as a covenant sign. Baptists, Pentecostals and Anabaptists baptise believers only, usually by immersion; Churches of Christ baptise believers “for the forgiveness of sins”.

Acts 2:38–39Romans 6:3–4Titus 3:51 Peter 3:21

In Zürich, 1525, Conrad Grebel re-baptised George Blaurock — the birth of the Anabaptist movement.

Is it right to baptize infants?

Does baptism itself wash away sin and give new birth?

Justification

How is a sinner made right with God? Protestants teach justification by grace through faith alone, with Christ’s righteousness imputed. Catholics teach justification by grace through faith working in love, with righteousness infused and growing. Orthodox frame salvation as theosis — union with God — rather than in legal terms.

Romans 3:28Ephesians 2:8–10James 2:24Galatians 5:6

Trent’s Decree on Justification (1547) answered the Reformers; the 1999 Joint Declaration found substantial Lutheran–Catholic agreement.

Are we justified by faith alone, apart from works?

Predestination & Assurance

Calvinists teach unconditional election and the perseverance of the saints: those God chooses will certainly be saved. Arminians (Methodists, most Pentecostals) teach election based on foreseen faith and that believers can fall away. Lutherans affirm election to salvation but reject double predestination; Catholics and Orthodox affirm grace and free cooperation.

Romans 8:29–30; 9:10–24Ephesians 1:4–5Hebrews 6:4–61 Timothy 2:4

The Synod of Dort (1618–19) answered the Remonstrants with the five points later summed up as “TULIP”.

Does God choose who will be saved before, and apart from, anything they do?

Can a truly saved person lose their salvation?

Original Sin

Western churches (following Augustine) teach that humanity inherits Adam’s guilt as well as a corrupted nature. Eastern churches speak of “ancestral sin”: we inherit mortality and a tendency to sin, not personal guilt. Some traditions (Latter-day Saints, Churches of Christ) teach that people are accountable only for their own sins.

Romans 5:12–19Psalm 51:5Ezekiel 18:20

Council of Carthage (418) condemned Pelagius, who denied that Adam’s sin affects his descendants.

Do we inherit Adam’s guilt, not just a fallen nature?

Holiness & Perfection

John Wesley taught “Christian perfection” or entire sanctification — a work of grace in which love so fills the heart that it no longer wilfully sins. The Holiness movement and early Pentecostals built on this. Most other traditions see sanctification as lifelong growth never complete before death.

Matthew 5:481 Thessalonians 5:231 John 3:6–9

Wesley’s “A Plain Account of Christian Perfection” (1766).

Can a Christian reach perfect love — freedom from willful sin — in this life?

Ministry & Church Order

Episcopal churches are led by bishops, and Catholics, Orthodox and Anglicans hold that valid orders come through apostolic succession. Presbyterian churches are governed by elders in graded councils; Baptists and other free churches by the local congregation. Women’s ordination is one of today’s sharpest divides, even within denominations.

Acts 14:231 Timothy 3:1–13Titus 1:5–9Galatians 3:28

Anglican provinces began ordaining women priests in the 1970s–90s; Catholic and Orthodox teaching reserve priesthood to men.

Do valid priests and bishops need ordination in an unbroken line from the Apostles?

Can women be ordained as pastors or priests?

Who should govern the church?

Mary

Ephesus (431) called Mary “Theotokos” — God-bearer — to protect the unity of Christ’s person. Catholics and Orthodox also hold her perpetual virginity; Catholics dogmatically define the Immaculate Conception (1854) and Assumption (1950). Most Protestants honour Mary as mother of Jesus but reject later Marian doctrines.

Luke 1:28–48Mark 6:3John 19:26–27

The Church of the East preferred “Christotokos” (Christ-bearer) and parted from the imperial church after 431.

Is it right to call Mary “Mother of God”?

Did Mary remain a virgin her whole life?

Saints & Icons

Catholic, Orthodox and Oriental churches ask the saints to intercede and venerate icons — honour passing to the person depicted, worship reserved to God alone. Lutherans keep images but do not invoke saints; Reformed and Anabaptist traditions removed images from worship.

Hebrews 12:1Revelation 5:8Exodus 20:4–5

Nicaea II (787) ended the first wave of Iconoclasm; the “Triumph of Orthodoxy” (843) is still celebrated each Lent.

Is it right to ask saints in heaven to pray for you?

Is it right to venerate icons and holy images?

Death & the Afterlife

Catholics teach purgatory, a final purification for the saved. Orthodox pray for the departed and speak of an intermediate state without defining purgatory. Most Protestants believe believers go directly to be with Christ. Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that the dead are unconscious until the resurrection.

2 Maccabees 12:44–461 Corinthians 3:12–15Philippians 1:23Ecclesiastes 9:5

Council of Florence (1439) defined purgatory; Luther’s 95 Theses (1517) began over indulgences.

What happens to believers when they die?

Gifts of the Spirit

Pentecostals and charismatics hold that every spiritual gift — tongues, prophecy, healing — continues today, and many teach a distinct baptism in the Spirit. Cessationists (many Reformed, Baptists and Churches of Christ) believe the sign-gifts ended with the apostles. Many traditions take a middle position.

Acts 2:1–41 Corinthians 12–14Joel 2:28

The Azusa Street Revival in Los Angeles (1906) launched global Pentecostalism.

Are tongues, prophecy and healing part of the Christian life today?

Worship & Practice

Some distinctives are about how Christians live and worship: Seventh-day Adventists keep the Saturday Sabbath; Anabaptists and Quakers refuse military service; Churches of Christ sing a cappella, as do Orthodox (by tradition rather than rule). These questions often pinpoint a tradition quickly.

Exodus 20:8–11Matthew 5:38–44Ephesians 5:19Psalm 150

The Schleitheim Confession (1527) set out Anabaptist nonresistance; Adventists formally organised in 1863.

Which day must Christians keep holy?

May a Christian fight in war?

May churches use musical instruments in worship?

Legend